The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan

Zen and Branding: Drafting abstraction—the calligraphy of the empty mind and the absence of presence.

In our brand work, we’re always looking at how to “be there,” how to “present,”
how to offer solutions that are about context, place-making,
certainty of premise, a real promise and authenticity.

What if the promise is nothing[ness]?

While some might find the idea of aligning Zen principles to branding disjointing, it might come down to this—for one Zen master’s question, a kōan, Zen puzzle, to a monk, “what do you know—what’s your answer?”

The answer, for one, comes to the current state of awareness—well, what do you know?
“I only know what I know now.”

The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan
MichaelMaggs, CC BY-SA 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons

And it relates, as noted before, to the puzzle stone in the renown Zen Garden Ryōan-ji.
From that Wikipedia observation—an overview on the stone—and its meaning:
“Ryōan-ji also has a teahouse and tea garden, dating to the 17th century. Near the teahouse is a famous stone water basin, with water continually flowing for ritual purification. This is the Ryōan-ji tsukubai, which translates as “crouch”; because of the low height of the basin, the user must bend over to use it, in a sign of reverence and humility.[21] The kanji written on the surface of the stone basin, 五, 隹, 止, 矢, are without significance when read alone. Though the water basin’s frame is circular, the opening in the circular face is itself a square (口). If each of the four kanji is read in combination with 口 (the square-shaped radical is pronounced kuchi, meaning “mouth” or “aperture”), which the square opening is meant to represent, then the characters become 吾, 唯, 足, 知. This is read as “ware, tada taru (wo) shiru”, which translates literally as “I only sufficiency know” (吾 = ware = I, 唯 = tada = merely, only, 足 = taru = be sufficient, suffice, be enough, be worth, deserve, 知 = shiru = know)[21] or, more poetically, as “I know only satisfaction”. Intended to reinforce Buddhist teachings regarding humility and the abundance within one’s soul, the meaning is simple and clear: “one already has all one needs”. Meanwhile, the positioning of the tsukubai, lower than the veranda on which one stands to view it, compels one to bow respectfully (while listening to the endless trickle of replenishing water from the bamboo pipe) to fully appreciate its deeper philosophical significance.”

Each part of the character sequence relates to central square, a character modifier, which translates, as a puzzle, to “you only know what you know, now.” That of course is my interpretation of the kanji and radical renderings—but this is the key as it comes to the premise of strategic foundations of brand work, you start, you work through positioning and audience relationships, and your tactical outcomes of action steps in a manner that is always infused with the right now, the nowness of what you know, your full attention, your lean-in, listening. Or the “no” that leads to now — and the “yes” that contrasts that condition.

But what of nothingness? And the character Mu, as shown at the start of this blog?

That’s part of the puzzle of another Zen parable—the “Mu” koan, which is like an unanswerable question. It goes like this, according to Liza Dalby and her collective exploration of Mu. Her work is “Inspired by the Zen koan, ‘Does a dog have Buddha nature?’ the MU Collaboration (MuKorabu) project joins calligraphy and art by numerous artists in a non-conventional take on the traditional Asian hanging scroll.”

I participated.

This collaborative effort comes to these character expansions: The Japanese and Korean term mu (Japanese: 無; Korean: 무) or Chinese wú (traditional Chinese: 無; simplified Chinese: 无) meaning “not have; without” is a key word in Buddhism, especially Zen traditions.

Clearly, the idea of a koan
as a puzzling and abstract response are full of implications and variations on meaning.

Steve Heine, at the Oxford University Press’s Academic Insights for the Thinking World offers a series of studied, tiered implications, and offers a conclusion, which is not a conclusion, but a facet to the unanswerable: he notes in “the prominent twelfth century Chinese master, Daie: This approach takes the “Mu” response in a non-literal way to express a transcendental negation that becomes the topic of an intensive contemplative experience, during which any and all thoughts or uses of reason and words are to be cut off and discarded for good rather than investigated for their expressive nuances and ramifications.”

What that means, to one take, would be “much ado about nothing” is a waste of time: “nothing is nothing — meditate on that!”

So I did, at Liza Dalby‘s request,
to create an interpretation of nothingness.

And in my realm of contemplating nothing, I saw that as a gateway, a whorl into a deeper layering of experience — one in which storms and waves wheel and turn and roil in
the nothingness of everythingness.

For in the Zen context, everything is nothing.

So I drew it as a gateway into a landscape of strokes and movements the churn in the uncertainty of that premise; there is nothing in everything. There is everything in nothing. That, for me, is the gateway to nothing, and to everything. It’s closed and opening at the same time; it is the “gateless gate.”

When I use the brush for a rendering of anything, I’m looking into the deep part of the stroke and how that alchemy of ink transforms the white stock as a place of supernatural reality.

What happens there is magic, it’s the transformation of context between
what is known and
what is unknown,
what is newly known and
what is just discovered.

The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan

The piece starts with the core character, which is then contained in a whorl of grey calligraphy, a kind of enso into another universe.

The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan

You can see the initiative strokes
and the renderings
on top of the draftings,
the stroke sequence —
the move in,
further and further,
until there is
another world, whorled —
a talisman of nothingness.

The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan
The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan
The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan
The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan
The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan
The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan
The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan

Which
is
every
thing.

That final sequence is here.

And, to how this might relate finally, to a sense of brand strategy—as far a reach as it would appear—
would be as follows:

—Energy counts for everything.

—There should be depth to the thinking of the why and how a brand works, what it stands for.

—Work your way into strategy with a deeper meditation on construct; you’re here, why?

—You’re telling a story for what, for who?

—Commit to the deep brand space, the nebulous metaphors and allegories, then rise to increasing layers of accessibility.

—Stay true and show freely your world.

Tim
––––––––––––––––––––
Girvin | Osean | Tim.Girvin | Wanderer

Follow Us:
Facebook LinkedIn Instagram Behance

The Question of Nothingness | The Mu Kōan


Discover more from Girvin | Strategic Branding & Design

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.